About UCU
The University and College Union (UCU) is the largest trade union in the post-16 education sector in the UK, representing 120,000 academic and related members across the UK, and is the largest union in the higher education sector in Scotland.
UCU represents academic workers (including lecturers, researchers, professors, teaching fellows, graduate teaching assistants, post-graduate researchers and other “early careers” academics, etc.), as well as academic related professional support staff (including librarians, administrators, IT staff, student support staff, human resources staff etc.) in Scottish higher education institutions. In Scotland UCU organise only in the higher education sector and our comments on the bill therefore focus predominantly on how the bill impacts universities.
Prior evidence on the bill
UCU welcomes many of the amendments being proposed to the bill, particularly around the governance of universities. UCU submitted evidence on governance reform in the bill to the committee in the evidence gathering stage and ahead of the stage one debate. UCU’s Scotland official, Mary Senior, spoke to our evidence and outlined possible areas of governance reform and limiting senior pay in universities at the committee’s meeting in May.
Amendments
UCU’s views on some of the proposed amendments are below:
50. On compliance with fair work criteria. Miles Briggs MSP: UCU would support the inclusion of requiring fundable bodies to comply with fair work criteria specified in this and other amendments. We have a wider complaint about fair work criteria and guidance and how it is applied to the higher education sector, believing that the bar for universities being able to be graded as compliant is too low, and that the hierarchy of criteria means universities can say they are compliant while engaging in practices our members would regard as being anything but.
3. Pam Gosal MSP: On addressing gender-based violence against staff and students. UCU would support the inclusion of this.
52. Maggie Chapman MSP: On transparency and requiring publication of court papers. UCU supports increased transparency around decision making in universities and believes the amendment would add to this.
53. Maggie Chapman MSP: On good governance. We are unsure about the wording of this amendment given its reference to the code of good higher education governance being published by ministers, when the current code is produced by the chairs of court. UCU has complained in the past about the consultation process followed by the chairs of court when producing the code, most recently the 2023 code when – despite a promise made in 2017 to have an inclusive review in future, in our view, this was not done with consultation for the 2023 version only including unions at the very end of the process.
54. Ross Greer MSP: On court majority being elected by staff and students. UCU supports this amendment. This amendment is in-line with UCU policy agreed by UCU Scotland’s 2022 congress and the union’s long term asks around Scottish university governance reflecting its historically democratic basis and oversight reflecting the interests and make-up of universities’ key stakeholders; their staff and students.
55. Ross Greer MSP: On transparency in higher education. UCU Supports this amendment.
56. Pam Duncan-Glancy: On training for court members. UCU supports this amendment.
57. Maggie Chapman: On a governance publication scheme. UCU supports this amendment.
58. Maggie Chapman: On remuneration committees. UCU would be happy with the inclusion of staff and student representatives on remuneration committees being included in the bill, but we note that the 2023 code of good higher education governance states the expectation that consultation includes trade unions. The code also sets out that this could be achieved by the committee containing the relevant members of university governing bodies i.e. trade union nominees. We would not want to lose the requirement to consult with trade unions.
59. Maggie Chapman: On governance concerns, notifying the SFC and whistleblowing. UCU supports this amendment.
61. Ross Greer: On fair work. As per amendment 50, we would support this amendment.
61A. Ross Greer MSP: On principal’s and senior pay. UCU in our evidence to the committee argued that it was beyond time that limits were placed on ever increasing principals’ pay that bring the sector into disrepute and demoralise staff. UCU supports this amendment as an attempt to reign in the largesse towards principals’ pay in the university sector. Voluntary efforts and calls for restraint simply have not worked and it is time for action in this regard.
61B. Ross Greer MSP: On zero-hour contacts. UCU supports this amendment. There has been limited progress on ending zero-hour contracts in some institutions and the fair work criteria refer to ending their inappropriate use. In fact, UCU doesn’t see an appropriate use and their inclusion in the bill would be a welcome addition which UCU would support.
63. Miles Briggs MSP: On mental health support. UCU supports this amendment.
64. Pam Duncan-Glancy: On whistleblowing and protecting whistleblowers. UCU supports this amendment.
66. Pam Duncan-Glancy MSP: On the need to consult. UCU supports this amendment and the requirement to consult with trade unions and student representatives.
67. Pam Duncan-Glancy MSP: On eligibility requirements for senior lay members of court. UCU accepts the need for chairs of court to have suitable experience but, in our view, one of the failings in university governance which has led to increased managerialism and universities being run as businesses rather than educational institutions is the lack of diversity on governing bodies, including the long term overreliance on senior lay members coming predominantly from private-sector professional and managerial backgrounds rather than reflecting wider experiences in other sectors or backgrounds. We would ask committee members to be careful to ensure that amendments to the bill do not accentuate this. Our universities and their governance structures, including the chairs, should reflect the communities they are based in and not simply a single class, background or professional experience.
68. Pam Duncan-Glancy MSP: On parity of student and staff governing body members. UCU support this amendment. UCU members on courts have since the 2016 Higher Education Governance Act and before argued that they have not, in many institutions, been regarded as having parity with other court members both in governing body meetings and in committees and when being allocated committee membership. This amendment, in line with recent additions to the code, would be a welcome step in this regard.
133. Miles Briggs MSP: On removing governing body members. UCU would want members of the committee to be mindful of the role of government in relation to the governance of higher education instructions and avoid potential overreach, particularly if seeking to remove a member of the governing body who is there by right of having been elected, for example by the institutions’ academic council or senate, or being directly elected by staff or any other constituency.
14. Ben Macpherson: On the SFC’s powers of examination. UCU supports the amendment.
14A. Ross Greer MSP: On the SFC’s powers of examination re amendment 14. Given our support of amendment 14, we would also welcome the extension of those powers contained in both 14A and 14B.
14B. Ross Greer MSP: On the SFC’s powers of examination re amendment 14. Given our support of amendment 14, we would also welcome the extension of those powers contained in both 14A and 14B.
144. Ross Greer MSP: On the SFC enforcing compliance. UCU supports this amendment and, in particular the reference to and ability to have additional non-financial penalties.
17. Ben Macpherson MSP: On sharing information in relation to free school meals. UCU welcomes this amendment (and the similar amendment 197 from Pam Duncan-Glancy MSP) which would allow the sharing of information on access to free school meals for the purpose of widening access. This has been identified as necessary for many years, and the resolution of what is a technical problem in this bill is very welcome. Whether amendment 17 or 197 best does this isn’t something UCU would be able to comment on.
177. Pam Duncan-Glancy MSP: On membership of the SFC board and including trade union membership. UCU welcomes this amendment and rectifying the imbalance on the existing board of university senior management and principals being well represented but there being no worker or trade union voice. This was an ask of UCU’s, along with other unions, during the early stages of the bill’s passage and we are thankful to Pam Duncan-Glancy for this amendment which we wholly support. We acknowledge too, the specific reference to trade union voices from staff, further education, and higher education all of which represent different constituencies with a direct interest in the work of the funding council.
180. Miles Briggs MSP: On membership of the SFC board and including trade union membership. We welcome the reference to trade union membership, but think the requirement in amendment 177 that defines union representatives from different sectors rather than just fundable bodies is helpful to ensure representation from across the sectors the SFC is responsible for.